Writing about fear: An afternoon excursion in Nişantaşı (Part 2)


Nişantaşı (Image by Isik5 at deviantart.com)

Nişantaşı (Image by Isik5 at deviantart.com)

Note to readers: This is the second in a series of posts about my writing on fear as part of the worldwide, place-passionate group of writers called #38Write. I chose to write about fear in the context of my Turkish-American marital roadtrip. Specifically, I am exposing and exploring my embarrassing fear of walking around by myself in Istanbul. You can read the seeds of how this came to be here.

In the last 24 hours or so, I have realized that my fear – which I already KNEW was not based in a statistical reality – was more about honoring a different family culture, my husband’s. i realized this thanks to the illuminating comments from two other women married to Turks whose American-based husbands have similar fears for their wives – despite liberal values, etc. Also, from another comment-leaver, I realize that my fear also probably relates to becoming middle aged. I grew up traveling and was generally probably too fearless in some instances (traveling every line if the Moscow subways solo, exploring the world at the end of each line – with rudimentary Russia at age 14? After ditching the Intourist guide?)

In any case, I am truly grateful for the generous, thoughtful & kind comment-leavers from my last post who analyzed along with me, invited me to go out with them and just generally helped me to get to the next step in analyzing this crazy fear.

I want to be clear that It wasn’t that I feared what happened to Sarai Sierra for Myself as much as it was that her death stirred up my thinking on the topic. To think that I was afraid to walk around the wealthy areas of Nişantaşı or Şişli – is laughable to me today (she says, blushing).

In any case, today’s post is the story of one day, about two years ago, when I finally ventured out of the Istanbul apartment on my own. While fear and anxiety are all over this essay – I feel myself beyond this now…and I think my husband is not too far behind on this!

Just the bare bones of the call to prayer trickle through the window. I wonder if my husband is hearing this, the afternoon ezan, while visiting a friend on Buyuk Ada – I’m not even sure there is a mosque there. Everyone else is at work, and I am wasting the day away inside my Istanbul apartment prison. I have the card key to the apartment. I can leave if I want to. The outside taxi cacophony chills my skin with its whirs and whizzes. I contemplate my self-imposed confinement. My fingers and toes touch the leaded window over the neighborhood; the coursing warmth of the city just at the bottom of the hill.

My fear’s zenith propels my turn away from the window, to the door. I’m going to do it. The formal clank of the leaden door behind me amputates some fear. Blood pounds hypertense in my ears. Sunshine softens my goosebumps. I target the mall below, across the boulevard. I’m in the mood for some buttery, cheese-filled börek, why not step out for some?

Stinging doubts swarm me as soon as the thought is out. My husband’s fear, my brother-in-law’s fear and my Father’s fear merged into the idea of me, walking alone, in Istanbul. “I’m an experienced traveler – why is this happening? What’s the matter with me?” But I am circumnavigating the curling stairs to the street. My throat constricts in exhaust-fume chilled garage. I swallow the thickening mucus of fear. Once outside, I squint in the golden warmth, locating my New York street-crossing skills while dodging cars.

Entering the mall, it’s a familiar drill. Place the bag on the magnetometer. Greet the attendant with “Iyi Günler.” Walk on. My heart rusts as the smiling, familiar attendant greets me with more than the usual pleasantries. This guard with the modern blue hijab recognizes me. Blushing, I muster “sorry, don’t understand!” She rubs my shoulder knowingly, waives me on with a smile. I feel comfort for a moment – the fear in my mind’s eye distracted. I am known here.

Stepping onto the speeding escalator, I accidentally brush against a middle-aged man, and feel my skin is still on red alert. I don’t want him to get the wrong idea. He doesn’t seem to notice. I pose myself with the question – “what could happen in a shopping mall? Why am I worried about this?” I make sure my wedding ring is showing.

Cupping my lira in my pocket, I head for the börekci. I am so focused on practicing my order in mental loops, that I overshoot the entrance. Not wanting to look stupid, I walk around the block again for a second try. I try on an ‘I-belong-here’ swagger at entry. Grinning nervously, my Turkish is quickly answered in English. I slink to the farthest table. I spoon slow, deliberate portions of hot, buttery börek into my mouth. A few unadulterated moments of normalcy emerge from the noodles, maybe even some joy. Perhaps I should walk into Nişantaşı and sit in the park around the mosque? I begin to rationalize the idea, thinking “lots of women sit there with their kids. Isn’t the language of women and children universal? This is a modern city – this is not Tehran or Qatar. I don’t have to veil. I’m dressed more conservatively than my Turkish niece who left the house in a micro-mini this morning. I shouldn’t be fearful as a woman. I should just go out and walk around.”

As my plate cools, my worries begin to simmer again, “I should go home. This is enough. What if the building guard doesn’t recognize me? What if the key card to the apartment doesn’t work?” Oddly, my calm consumes these worries in one messy gulp. Warming to taking the long way home, I head out. My legs ache with shin splints as I negotiate the steep hill. Children are laughing and playing in the park – it’s just a block away. Traversing the park, I smile at the mothers and children, but I am unnoticed. All the park benches are filled, so I pretend to intentionally cross the street in an arc towards home. My brain is an odd mix of puffed up peacock and plummeting pigeon careening down the hill. My knees hurt from the angle of the street as I feel the comfort of the guard at my apartment block. He lets me pass. The key card works. The door closes me in again. I deflate, shivering in the cold air conditioning.

The clock tells me I was gone for about fifteen minutes.

Yavaş yavaş: On the work of managing childhood trauma


A boy and his father facing the waves of Hurricane Sandy

Lately, as you well know, dear readers, I am recovering from an injured (and re-injured) rotator cuff in my left shoulder (my writing side) – but what has started to happen during this period of slowed-down medical leave, has been painfully magical in ways that have nothing to do with that sore shoulder. I have realized that my workaholism, in part, stems from my childhood strategies for managing the witnessing of everyday trauma – the trauma my little sister inflicted upon herself directly, and on our family, indirectly in a physical way – but full-on in the mental and behavioral ways.

At this point, Kenne, the Queen of Manners, Etiquette and the Maintenance of Ladylike Behavior inserts her opinion in a shrill manner, stating: “maybe you should NOT air your, how do you say, “dirty laundry?” I pay her no mind.  This process I am going through is indeed work, and therefore fits with BlogHer’s December 2012 NaBloPoMo on the topic of work.

My little sister, who I love very much despite it all, is a person with “intellectual disability” as well as mental health issues – and certainly evidences some qualities associated with Autism as well.  Growing up, her violent, loud and blood-filled tantrums occurred daily – often more than once. My M. has entered an understandably angry and protective stance, which I sometimes feel is the most “Turkish macho” that I have ever seen in him (perhaps excluding the time we bought our car last spring).  M. does not agree with my assessment, and hates the word “macho” – often protesting that his Anne (Turkish word for mother) raised him with the stern expectation that he would NEVER “be a macho.” And he is true to this. M. is angry that my parents allowed me to live in the chaos of our home with my sister – and does not share my understanding of why they did so, and how they did the best they could.  He often says “I do not know how to deal with this violent behavior.” which he has only witnessed firsthand once, last Sunday night, after a family party.  Usually, that statement is followed by “in Turkey, people don’t take their kids with disabilities out of the home, they hide them.”  So, it is something that is apparently understandable in the Turkish cultural context – but not in OUR context, here and now.  We are working through it as a couple.

A little boy trying to block out a scary hurricane

And I am working on all of this individually as well, feeling, in some ways, the effects of her violence for the first time just this week after a particularly nasty tantrum my sister engaged in while we were driving home.  Yes this has been going on for years, but I think I just blocked it out for years as a coping mechanism to “stay safe.” So, as I am getting in touch with how 42 years of my sister’s crashing, banging and yes, bloody tantrums have impacted me – even with the many years I was not with her directly, I am working on writing several stories on the topic – from the perspective of a little girl, but with some of the knowledge of this grown up lady.

And, I am taking a brave step in sharing one of these stories, Living in Hurricane House, which is written from the perspective of the sibling of someone like my sister.  My sister’s behavior in this story is de-personalized as a “howly and growly hurricane.” In the story, the little girl speaks of her “important, focusing, packing work” – this comes from the anxiety dream I have had as a kid, recently deconstructed.  I, along with my therapist, hope that my writing on the topic will hasten the healing that needs to happen.  I would love any feedback you would care to offer, however critical.

ONE

Once upon a time, there was a girl who lived in a house full of howly, growly hurricanes.

Usually, she ran from room to room to find the least windy, dangerous place.

Sometimes she saw the lights go out because the power lines were down again.

Sometimes she saw furniture, dishes and lamps crash from the weight of the wind.

Sometimes she saw water flying at her horizontally.

While she was running from room to room, she saw a lot, but she pretended not to see it.

She got good at ignoring it and just living with it.

TWO

That girl, she wished she could go outside of that house full of hurricanes.

She saw flowers and trees out there.

She saw fields and mountains out there.

She saw birds and bees out there.

She got good at ignoring all that out there, and just living with the howly and growly hurricanes.

THREE

And even though this girl lived in hurricane house, this little girl always had a lot of work to do.

She had to pack things up to be ready to go any minute.

Just in case the hurricane got really bad.  Just in case her parents thought she was not OK.

She had to focus her mind away from the howler and growler hurricanes, and perform.

Sometimes she had to pack food in brown paper bags or live lobsters in flower pots

Sometimes she had to pack big clothes in tiny suitcases, or goldfish in cardboard boxes

Sometimes she had to pack many blow-dryers in plastic supermarket bags, or fragile lilies on coat hangers

Sometimes she had to pack bananas in bandaid tins, and giraffes in pasta colanders

She had to pack all these crazy things up to be ready to go any minute, just in case that hurricane got REALLY howly and growly.

She got good at ignoring how scared she was of those hurricanes, and how resentful she was of all that hard packing work, and focused on just living with those howlers and growlers. That was all she could do.

 FOUR

As the hurricanes howled and growled, she felt worse and worse in her focusing packing work, because she always had an inappropriate container for her job, and her job was very important.

And when this girl had an inappropriate container with which to do her job, which was always, it looked like this to her:

She was always late, someone was always yelling at her to hurry, so she couldn’t hear her thoughts.

She was always trying to calm her squeezing heartbeat so she wouldn’t get pushed around by the wind.

She was always trying to breathe deep so she wouldn’t faint from it all, so she could block it out.

She was always feeling like crying, but didn’t dare let out one salty tear for fear the rain would wash it away and nobody would notice.

She got good at ignoring all those feelings, and instead just focused on living with the hurricanes.

 FIVE

And this whole hurricane and focused packing scene went on for a long time.

Longer than clocks can tick.

Longer than days can dawn.

Longer than weeks can amble along.

And she just kept on trying to pack, with her inappropriate containers, and ignored all those feelings, and instead just focused once more on living with her hurricanes, and creating more and more emergency packing strategies – and doing test runs, a lot.

Those hurricanes, they were not very friendly. Yes, they were howly and growly, and it wasn’t pretty.

 SIX

And then one windy, wet day in hurricane house, a glowing presence appeared.

“Hello, I am your sunshine Godmother”

She didn’t know she had a sunshine Godmother, or what a sunshine Godmother was.

“Sweetheart,” said the sunshine Godmother, “maybe all this packing is just TOO MUCH for you to do, it’s not that you have inappropriate containers for your important packing work. Those howlers and growlers, they need to go.”

She had never thought of that, that those howly growly hurricanes needed to go.

She had never thought it was all just TOO MUCH.

She had never thought it was all just TOO MUCH to do, that focused packing.

She had never thought anything besides the fact that she was less than a good worker, because she had always had an inappropriate container with which to do her work.

And her sunshine Godmother helped her to feel warm, dry and a bit more calm about her important packing job even in the most howly and growly times when the hurricanes were extra furious.

She couldn’t ignore that, and the hurricanes began to raise their eyebrows despite their howly growly ways.  They were onto a change in the weather coming their way, and they did not like it.

 SEVEN

And then one day, that girl, she woke up to a different house.

That little girl, she presumed she was dreaming.

It was not windy.

It was not howly and growly.

It was not wet.

And it looked different, really different.

And her sunshine Godmother explained these things – “light,” “dry,” “warm” and “color.”

And right there and then, in something she was learning to call light, that little girl rubbed her eyes and sat up to see all the colors of the rainbow around her.

And right there and then, in something she was learning to call dry, that little girl looked around her and the only water she saw were the dewdrops on the flowers outside of her window.

And in that thing called warm, that little girl felt her body relax and felt that warmth on her face as she stuck her head out of the window.

She smelled the flowers.

She heard the birds.

And that little girl saw the hurricanes, all howly and growly, far away now.

“They may come back,” her sunshine Godmother said, “but you’ll know how to find this other place now.”

“You’ll be just fine.”

On escaping the “emotion work” of everyday life in Istanbul


A man walking in Istanbul - image from the Reblog Phlog

A man walking in Istanbul – I wonder about the state of his emotion work with that wonderful and complicated city (Image from the Reblog Phlog)

On Sunday, I wrote that living in a Turkish-American marriage, you notice some cultural differences right away – and others slowly by slowly.

In thinking about cultural differences in this roadtrip called our marriage, work is a key piece when it comes to cultural difference – and as my theme of the month is “work,” due to my participation in Blogher’s NaBloPoMo, a discussion on “emotion work” as the sociologists call it, seems appropriate. “Emotion work” is defined as the management of one’s own feelings or as work done in a conscious effort to maintain the well being of a relationship – and in the case of this blog post – I am talking about the relationship between a person and their city, specifically, M. and Istanbul.

An image from the famous Cafe Algiers (Image by Neonlike at Flikr)

Let me go back some years, to the first date I had with my now husband. Sitting in the glow of warm light in Cafe Algiers, M. and I began the dance of getting to know one another. One of the first things I asked him related to the differences he noticed between his former life in Turkey and his present life in the United States.

“Oh,” he said, as if pained by an attack of acute gastritis (and eye rolling), “Turkey – Turkey – living there is just so much WORK. I was planning to move to a smaller city on the coast before I came here – Istanbul is just SO DIFFICULT.” I don’t recall the rest of that conversation – but I did wonder what the heck he meant, having never visited one of the second or third world’s mega-metropolis-cities at the time. I think my follow-up question was deflected elsewhere as we ordered a second cup of coffee before heading out for a walk along the Charles.

When M. did invite me to visit Turkey with him, to meet his family – and learn about that side of himself, I started to understand what he meant about the work of living in Istanbul – and it was indeed “emotion work” – just with a city this time. It didn’t take long,sitting in traffic, going in and out of markets, museums and watching M. trying to get a few bits of bureaucratic business done, I began to realize why living in Turkey might feel like so much WORK.

Istanbul traffic

Istanbul traffic (Photo credit: quicksilver_)

One day, sitting together in a cab without air conditioning, stuck in a a tangle of traffic like none I had ever seen, M. revisited the topic of the “work” of “just living” in Istanbul. Visibly frustrated – and a tinge sad if my eyes did not deceive me – he explained “This is why I left Istanbul, this is draining, like emotional work, just to get from one place to another.” He went on to describe the massive influx of immigrants from the eastern part of the country over the past 20-30 years that had changed his city of 7 million to one of 17 million seemingly in the blink of an eye. Of course, the city’s infrastructure could not smoothly absorb all of this – making day to day movement, well, work.

And then there were the queues – or rather – the lack thereof. Raised by very orderly people in a country in which queues are only slightly less relied upon than in Britain, I was shocked at the mad dash and super crush of humanity at the entrance to any particular venue – mosque, store, museum, move, restaurant, all of it. This image truly gets at the difference. And I learned too, that this, for my husband, had become intolerable “emotion work” as an Istanbullu, part of what eventually led him to live in this country. “Nothing,” he says with a frustrated sigh, “is easy, and over time that wears you down. When you want something – you have to battle with everyone to get to the front of the counter – there is no order, no peace.”

I believe that M’s dislike of the emotion work of living in Istanbul is a reflection of culture shift – from an eastern approach in which the present, comfort and balance were much closer at hand than in this globalized era. Now, this may also relate to his family’s class status – but I would argue we are a pretty good match in that department, so my bet is on cultural difference. And given his escape, I think that is why he is particularly happy with the boundaries around his professional work. And so how does this impact me? Well, it gives me a lot of food for thought.  The “emotion work” of living in our city is nothing compared to Istanbul – but given my recent workaholic collapse as a University professor and with my left shoulder injury to boot, I have a lot of time to re-consider my relationship with work – including the “emotion work” of academia.  But that, dear readers, is a post for another time.

And you – what about the “emotion work” in your life? I would love to hear your thoughts!